love and live are like dancing. you learn how to perform the best with the music playing
Monday, December 10, 2012
Historical School of Law
“ We are what we
repeatedly do. Excellence then, is not an act, but a habit.” – Aristotle
(384BC-322BC)
The Key Figures:
1.
Friedrich von Savigny (1779-1861), “Law is never
created but it grows along with its society.”
2.
G.V. Puchta (1798-1846), “Law is like a living
organism. It is simply like language.”
3.
Sir Henry Maine, “Law is unikum.”
According to Savigny:
1.
There is no individual-humans, only
social-humans;
2.
Law is never created but it grows along with
society;
3.
Law is ‘supra-individuals’ (social phenomena)
related to history in its society;
4.
In primitive society, law is created without any
engineering process through the spirit of its society (Volksgeist);
5.
The Volksgeist is maintained with the supports
of political and technical elements.
Savigny believes that law is one
of several factors in the life of a nation such as language, custom, moral, and
constitution. So law is something ‘supra-individual’ or a symptom of society.
LAW = CULTURAL EXPRESSION/ REFLECTION OF THE SPIRIT OF NATION
Description: Law is never created.
It grows along with its society and is in line with the norms. Simply said law
is the spirit of its nation. It is simultaneously flowing in circle.
Law is like a language. There is
no moment of absolute cessation. It grows with the growth of society and
strengthens with the strength of the people, and finally dies away as the
nation loses its nationality.
The weakness is the positive law
is blurred (or maybe it’s a good one? LOL), and the progress of law is
depending on the society itself. It can be improved as long as is in line with
the spirit of the nation.
So it is hard to develop the law when the influence
from outside or external factor pushes and pulls the law.
The good point is, the law will
always fit the society because it is the spirit of the society itself.
The example of this thought is
customary law. I actually like this thought so I’ll keep it on my mind :)
I hope you can get what I was
trying to say, sorry for the mistakes! :*
Legal Positivism
“ We never know other’s
will until it is expressed to us”
Legal Positivism has 5 main ideas:
1. Laws are commands of human being;
2. There is no necessary connection between law and morals ( or 'law as it is' and 'law as it ought to be');
3. The analysis ( or study of meanings of legal concept is worth pursuing) ;
4. the legal system is a close logical system in which correct legal decisions can be deduced by logical means from predetermined legal rules without references to social aim, policies, moral standard;
5. Moral judgements cannot be established or defended as statements or fact by rational argument, evidence or proof (non-cognitivism in ethics).
there are 2 types of legal positivism:
1. analytical jurisprudence
according to John Austin,
LAW = COMMAND OF THE SOVEREIGN
the expression of an act of wishing -> the will theory of law
according to Bentham and austin, law exists when population has developed the custom of "obidience" to a certain command. this kind of obidience sets forth the law.
A law is completely enacted only when the words constituting it are so precise that it maybe applied merely with the help of a dictionary.
so, command is the expression of wish and the sanctions are very essential (it has been in everyone's mind). Austin believes that legal norm is not dynamic and basis for legal validity depends on the factual situation.
2. the pure norm theory
according to Hans Kelsen, law should be separated from moral.
Positive law = what the law it is. Moral = what the law ought to be.
In Kelsen's perspective, law lives in "das sollen" and not in "das sain". It focuses on the norm, not the real conduct. Norms consists of basic norm and individual norm. This pure theory discribes positive law as an objectively valid order and states that this interpretation is possible only under the condition that a basic norm is presupposed. The legal system is organized in a hierarchical structure.
It is pure because it believes that law has to be clear from non- juridical aspects such as ethics, sociology, politics and history.
According to Kelsen, command is a normative character and the sanctions of law are essential but it follows the norm (casuistic). Legal norm is dynamic and the basic norm depends on the Grundnorm.
well legal realism states that the legal responsibility is determined by the norm, not by the logical relationship between norm and facts.
Legal Positivism = Formal Jurisprudence
Natural law thought
“An unjust law is no law”
Natural law is law that the norms come from God, from
universe and from human reason. Therefore natural law is described as eternal
law. Law never changes, never vanishes, and is applied by its own.
Natural law thought believes that right brings about the
law, not vice versa. Positive law should be in line with morality, if not then
that positive law would be invalid.
According to Thomas Aquinas, “Morality comes from natural
law. (The highest level of law is determined by God).”
According to Fuller, “ Morality comes from the legal system
itself. It is an internal part of the legal system (especially the principle of
legality).”
According to Dworkin and Fuller, morality is decided, not
discovered. It is not given.
LAW=NORMS (FAIRNESS
AND JUSTICE VALUES)
There are two principles:
1.
Justice principle (God’s reason) – It is true
and just because it is ordered by God
2.
Truth principle (Human’s reason) – It has been
true and just, therefore God is willing to order it.
Justice consists of procedural justice (fairness) and
substantive justice (the true justice).
According to St. Agustine (354-430),
Metaphysics is the first philosophy as the initial science to know God and
Philosophy is the underling of theology. Lex
aeterna is the plan (disposition) from God for the whole universe. Lex naturalis is the persistent plan
that is located inside human’s mind so everyone is able to grasp it.
There are three version of Natural law thought:
1. Traditional version
According to Surya Prakash Sinha, divine
law is not the same with lex divina. In his perspective, divine law is supreme
because the whole universe is governed by divine reason. Not all of divine law
is intelligible to human. The intelligible part reveals itself through eternal
law. Principles of eternal law are revealed in natural law and from natural law
are derived all human laws.
2. Inner morality version
According to Lon Fuller (1902-1978), Positive
law should be I line with morality. If not, it is still valid as long as it is
not contradictory with “inner morality of law”
3. Interpretive version
According to Ronald Dworkin, Positive law
should be I line with morality. If not, it is still valid as long as it can be
still morally interpreted. Law is not universally recognized as immanent
natural law. So, law is the result of legal thinking constructions of legal
practitioners. It’s a matter of interpretation.
School of thoughts
Hello again! I’ve been recently taught about ‘school of
thoughts’ and I’m going to share what these bloody thoughts are about. Don’t
get on your nerves because it doesn’t as complicated as it sounds.
School of thought is different from research methods.
Research methods are the methods that are used by the researcher to obtain the
information for his research. Meanwhile school of thought is the way of thinking in philosophy. Get
the different?
Now the matter is, is that important to learn? *yawn* Yes it is! When you learn something
from only one perspective and blindly close your other perspectives just to
make yourself confident and comfortable, you will lose your chance to gain more
knowledge and mislead yourself into the dark of dumbness.
I’ll explain six
school-of-thoughts:
1.
Natural
law thought
2.
Legal
positivism
3.
Historical
school of law
4.
Utilitarianism
5.
Legal
realism
6.
Sociological
Jurisprudence
Each explanation
will be posted on different posting J Enjoy!
Philosophy of Law
Now we enter the main topic, which is Philosophy of Law.
What is philosophy of law? It is simply philosophy that is
applied on law.
According to MR. Soetika, “Philosophy of law is seeking the essence of law; knowing what
lies behind law; researching the principles of law as value consideration;
giving deliberation and values and the explanation of the values; postulating
the law to the very basic; trying to get the roots of law.”
According to Mahadi, “Philosophy of law is philosophy about law, philosophy about
everything in the field of law to the roots deeply.”
According to Satjipto Raharjo, “Philosophy of law studies the fundamental
questions of law; Philosophy of law undertakes legal materials from different
perspectives; Science of positive law only deals with a particular legal
order.”
According to Lili Rasjidi, “Philosophy of law is trying to make the ethics world as a
background that isn’t touched by the five senses, turns into a normative
science; Philosophy of law is trying to find the ideal law that is able to be
the ‘legal basis ‘ and ‘ethics’ for the operation of a society system of
positive law.”
According to Gustav Radbruch:
“ Philosophy of law
contains three aspects:
1.
Aspect of Justice: justice is equality of rights for all people
in court;
2.
Aspect of Purpose: finality, which is determining the substance
of law, because the substance of law is indeed in line with the purpose of law
that is wanted to achieve;
3.
Aspect of Legal certainty or legality: guaranteeing that law is
able to serve as a rule that must be obeyed.”
According to Jan Gijssels and Mark
Van Hoeke, philosophy of law has several studies:
1.
Ontology of Law
Study of the essence of law (The essence of
democracy, relation between law and moral)
2.
Epistemology of Law
Study of legal knowledge (form of
meta-philosophy)
3.
Axiology of Law
Study of determining the substances and
values of law ( Such as eligibility, equality, justice, freedom, rights, etc)
4.
Logics of Law
5.
Ideology of Law
Study of idea
6.
Teleology of Law
Study of meaning and purpose of law
7.
Science of Law
Meta-theory of legal science
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)







